Advertising Sponsored by the sellers of Beyond Brew

Top 5 Coffee Alternatives of 2024

Learn more about the hottest health trend for energy + focus


The Benefits of Coffee Alternatives

  • Energy Without The Crash
  • Promotes Digestion
  • Supports Immune Functioning
  • Enhances Focus & Concentration
  • Improved Sleep Quality
  • Heart-Health Support

Coffee Alternative Buying Guide

If coffee is hard on your stomach, gives you the jitters, or keeps you up at night, then this hot new health trend is for you. More and more people are saying 'no' to coffee and 'yes' to mushroom-infused coffee alternatives.

The best coffee alternatives contain ingredients that promote focusmore restful sleep, and less everyday stress. These can be used instead of coffee or to help replace your second or third cup. Some people even mix them into their coffee for added benefits.

But with dozens to choose from, it can be difficult to know which ones work, and which aren't worth your money. After all, only a few products in this space have enough mushrooms to actually be effective. 

That’s why the ShopOwl research team put together this quick guide to help you pick a quality coffee alternative that gives you the boost you need to be at the top of your game.

Why Drink Coffee Alternatives?

Coffee alternatives are an excellent way to infuse your body with nutritious ingredients at the start of each day. While you won't experience the same feeling as coffee, many have found that they're able to remain focused, alert, and energetic without stomach issues or jitters.

Another added benefit is the quality of your sleep will be enhanced by having less caffeine in your system. This alone does wonders for the immune system and energy levels if maintained over time.

What to Look for & Avoid in a Coffee Alternative

Here are the top ingredients to look for in high-quality coffee alternatives that promote focus, alertness, and overall wellness:

  • Look For
  • Functional Mushroomsiber  - Reishi, Chaga, Cordyceps sinensis, and Cordyceps militaris.
  • Probiotics + Prebiotics maintain a healthy gut bacteria, immune system, and blood sugar levels.
  • Fiber - 95% of Americans don't get enough fiber, a key ingredient for maintaining heart health. 
  • Avoid
  • Excessive Caffeine -  Some coffee alternatives contain almost as much caffeine as a regular cup of coffee.
  • Pure Mushroom Formulas - If the ingredients only contain mushrooms then it's likely that it won't taste that good, making it psychologically more difficult to stay away from coffee.

Beware of Artificial Sweeteners & Flavors

Many supplements on the market include artificial flavors and sweeteners to improve the taste of coffee alternatives. Make sure any extra sweetener is derived naturally (like stevia or erythritol), since synthetic sugar may cause unpleasant side effects in some people. 

What Else To Consider Before Purchasing

Finding a coffee alternative that lists all the ingredients mentioned above is crucial, but it’s also important to consider these guidelines before you buy: 

Transparent List of Ingredients

Many coffee alternatives only list a handful of their key ingredients. The ingredients on the label should match the ones on their website. If they're inconsistent, then it's likely that brand is trying to hide an ingredient they don't want you to know about.

Money-Back Guarantee

Buying a supplement with a 90-day money-back guarantee shows the company believes in its product, and will allow you to try it without any risk to you.

01

a pink box with a labelBeyond Brew
Sold by: Live Conscious1


Owned by ShopOwl's brand partners
Marketplace Rating:

Adjusted Rating:

Buy On Amazon

A+

  • Quality RankA
  • Review RankA
  • Value RankA
Close Full Analysis
Quality Rank A

99/100

After our algorithm searched over 5,000 data points and analyzed 52 variables, Beyond Brew received a high score for its superior quality. 

Review Rank A 

100/100

Although there are not many reviews yet, our algorithm determined that a majority of the reviews for this product are accurate. 

Value Rank A 

95/100

Considering these different variables, we determined that this product has a good purchase value. 

Marketplace Rating:
Adjusted Rating:

97.3

of 100

02

Organic Mushroom Coffee
Sold by: Micro Ingredients


ShopOwl earns a commission when you click on the link to make a purchase
Marketplace Rating:

Adjusted Rating:

Buy On Amazon

A

  • Quality RankB
  • Review RankA
  • Value RankA
Close Full Analysis
Quality Rank B

89/100

After our algorithm searched over 5,000 data points and analyzed 52 variables, Micro Ingredients received an above average score for its quality. 

Review Rank A 

100/100

Our algorithm determined that roughly 100% of reviews were genuine. 

Value Rank A 

95/100

We've determined that this product has an A value rank due to the slightly lower price point.  

Marketplace Rating:
Adjusted Rating:

95.0

of 100

03

a jar of foodMud\Wtr
Sold by: Mud\Wtr


ShopOwl earns a commission when you click on the link to make a purchase
Marketplace Rating:

Adjusted Rating:

Buy On Amazon

B+

  • Quality RankB
  • Review RankA
  • Value RankB
Close Full Analysis
Quality Rank B

83/100

After our algorithm searched over 5,000 data points and analyzed 52 variables, Mud\Wtr is an above average score for its quality. 

Review Rank A 

100/100

Our algorithm determined that roughly 100% of reviews were genuine. 

Value Rank B 

86/100

We've determined that this product has a B value rank due to the slightly higher price point.  

Marketplace Rating:
Adjusted Rating:

89.6

of 100

04

packaged goodsJoe'y
Sold by: Joe'y


ShopOwl earns a commission when you click on the link to make a purchase
Marketplace Rating:

Adjusted Rating:

Buy On Amazon

B+

  • Quality RankB
  • Review RankA
  • Value RankB
Close Full Analysis
Quality Rank B 

82/100

After our algorithm searched over 5,000 data points and analyzed 52 variables, Joe'y received a B grade for its quality.

Review Rank A 

100/100

Our algorithm marked 100% of the reviews as genuine.

Value Rank B

80/100

Considering the somewhat strong quality rank and the strong review rank, our algorithm has determined that this product has a B value rank. 

Marketplace Rating:
Adjusted Rating:

87.3

of 100

05

packaged goodsMushroom Coffee
Sold by: Everyday Dose


ShopOwl earns a commission when you click on the link to make a purchase
Marketplace Rating:

Adjusted Rating:

Buy On Amazon

B

  • Quality RankC
  • Review RankA
  • Value RankB
Close Full Analysis
Quality Rank C 

75/100

After our algorithm searched over 5,000 data points and analyzed 52 variables, Ryze Mushroom Coffee received an average score for its quality. 

Review Rank A 

100/100

Our algorithm has discovered that 100% of the reviews are high quality.

Value Rank B 

80/100

We've determined that this product has an B value rank due to its lower quality, but advantageous price point.  

Marketplace Rating:
Adjusted Rating:

85.0

of 100